IDEOTRONDeutsch

← All ideas of the day

Comic mystery / short film 2026-11-16

Number 212

Hook

Dev, 31, is number 212 on the waiting list for the Holloway Lane allotments. The secretary estimates his wait at 38 years, since plots only come free when a holder dies or fails the monthly inspection. Dev notices that Plot 19, registered to an Arthur Pinnock, is the best-kept plot on the site, and that nobody has ever seen Arthur Pinnock.

Escalation
  1. Dev stakes out the allotments one night, hoping to catch Arthur and maybe charm his way into sharing the plot. Instead he sees at least a dozen headtorches moving between the beds, quietly weeding, earthing up leeks and tying in beans on plots all over the site.
  2. He checks the parish burial records. Arthur Pinnock died in 2009, and so did the holders of Plots 4, 11, 23 and 30. At least a third of the registered tenants are dead, and someone is still paying their rent in cash every January.
  3. Furious, Dev drafts a complaint to the council. Exposing the fraud would free about thirty plots overnight and move him to the top of the list. Before he can send it, a council notice goes up: if active tenancy falls below 60%, the land will be considered 'underused' and offered to a developer. Reporting the dead would hand the whole site to the bulldozers.
  4. The next morning there's a jar of pickled beetroot on his doorstep with a note in it: 'Shed 7. Sunday. Bring gloves.'
✦ Twist

In Shed 7 the night gardeners give Dev Arthur Pinnock's rent book, his seed tin and his flat cap. Then they explain how the list works. It was never a queue. It's a vetting list, and everyone ahead of him is already out at night tending a dead man's plot under that man's name. Dev was number 212 because 211 people had said yes before him. His first job is to learn Arthur's handwriting for the show-bench labels, because Arthur has won Best Onion four years running.

💡 Any normal way of getting a plot would destroy the place Dev wants to join, so he can only get what he wanted by becoming someone who isn't there.

♥ Save this idea Build your own idea →